A lot of Christians will tell you that their beliefs are clearly outlined in Scripture and that the Bible is their one true measure for sound doctrine. I'm fine with these kind of assertions and would encourage all Christians to read the Scriptures and live by them. The problem, however, is that not all Christians who read the Bible and try to live by it do so in communion with the rest of Christianity.
The obvious question here is why all "Bible-Believing" Christians don't go to the same church and do not share the same doctrines and religious practices? If God is speaking to us through the Scriptures, why are we not all hearing the same thing? It's a valid question, right? And I'm sure it's a question that opponents to Christianity ask as well.
Now the problem with the it's-just-me-and-my-Bible approach to Christianity is not the "Bible" part of course, it's the "just me" part. With this philosophy, each person ends up being his own chief bishop in a diocese of one. And when everyone is his own judge of what true Christianity is, conflicts often arise and communion is far too often broken. Sadly, parting ways with other Christians is quite easy, since the average North American town has 58429658122458 different churches in it and you could start attending a new one and never see your former church buddies again - except for those rare and unfortunate run-ins at the supermarket (or,
cringe the liquor store). In reaction to this ideological chaos, churches end up continually adjusting to the latest teaching and worship fads to keep attendance up, as "church shoppers" file in and out through their revolving front doors.
When did being a Christian become such a lonely endeavour? Why is the "church" so split up and scattered?
Here's the thing: the Bible was not inscribed by the hand of God on a stone tablet for us. It did not float down out of heaven on a cloud either. Because of this, we have to accept that humans were given authority by God to preach the Gospel and found the Christian Church. Jesus didn't say to his disciples "here guys, just take this copy of the
NIV and share it with as many people as possible." And Christ surely could have written a book, but he didn't. He built relationships with his disciples instead and taught them how to follow him. Then, he imparted his power to them and commissioned them to preach the Gospel to the whole world.
And here's a good question: what do you think happened for the first few hundred years of Christianity before the New Testament canon of Scripture was decided and for the 1500 years before the printing press was invented? Yeah, that's right, not everyone had a Bible, as we know it, to read. But that was fine because God, wise, loving Father that He is, had it covered. He had a good and more than sufficient plan to sustain His Church so that the "gates of hades would not prevail against it," without requiring all Christians to own a Bible.
Most importantly, He sent the Holy Spirit to empower, give life to, speak truth to and comfort Christians. Secondly, Christ commissioned his Apostles and the traditions he gave them were passed on from bishop to bishop through the ages. Finally, the one thing that must never be forgotten: God fills us with his love and this love is what is supposed to set us apart from the rest of the world and bind us together in communion.
Now, just from reading some of St. Paul's Epistles, you would wonder how Christianity made it out of the first century, since Christians were coming up with bad doctrines and dividing over them almost immediately. However, regardless of the fact that the New Testament had not yet been written and the Gospel had to be spread by 12 guys who were travelling mostly by foot, the Christian Church grew and thrived. The Apostles laid hands on people and they received the gift of the Holy Spirit. They passed on the teachings of Christ, baptising these new "
Christians" in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. They worked miracles, had visions, healed people and were instantly transported great distances for the sake of the Gospel. They were given authority by Christ and filled with the Holy Spirit for their mission
and these were no small gifts.
Despite all of the challenges they faced, they were all "of one accord." They agreed with each other and when they didn't, they worked it out and came to a mutual understanding. They must have had some difficult conversations for sure, but never did they say "Oh well, Paul can go have his gentile church and Peter can go have his Jewish church." They knew the body of Christ was not to be divided like that! They knew that the message of the Gospel would be destroyed if such divisions were to take place. St. Paul later wrote to the Galatians "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female;
for you are all one in Christ Jesus." (ch 3 vs 28).
Here is another blatant fact: not all of the Apostles teachings were written in the New Testament Scriptures. To do so really would have been impossible, for they each spent the rest of their lives tending to the flocks God gave them, teaching them by word and example all the while. 2 Thessalonians 2:15 demonstrates this fact: St. Paul writes "Therefore, brethren, stand fast and
hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle" and later he exhorts "But we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw from every brother who walks disorderly and not according to the tradition which he received from us. For you yourselves know how you ought to follow us, for we were not disorderly among you..." (2 Thes 3: 6-7).
Christian life involves action, imitation of Christ and a working out ones salvation through acts of love, mercy and humility. It's not just academic, it is practical and the Apostles had to share this aspect of faith through example. They had to demonstrate what a godly life looked like. And not only is Christianity practical, it is
sacramental. Sacraments are things in which we participate. They can be written about, but to learn them and experience them, you need to "be there." Simply try to imagine all the many things the Apostles must have taught the churches through their physical presence and by the passing on of the Sacraments of baptism and chrismation, the holy Eucharist, anointing of the sick, ordination, confession and marriage.
Over time, the Christian faith was also taught, preserved and passed on through
hagiography, hymnography and
iconography. The Seven
Ecumenical Councils also played a very important role in the history and development of the Christian faith and cannot be discounted or ignored. They helped the Christian Church formulate its theology, refute heresy and come to consensus on very important matters of faith and practice. It was from the first two Ecumenical Councils that we received the
Nicene Creed - a statement of faith that is shared by Orthodox Christians to this day. This creed unites Christians in mutual faith.
The most important thing however is that Christ is our source of Life and this unites us to each other.
That which binds Christians together is the love of Christ: love that trampled down death by death, love that pulls us up from the pit, love that sets our feet on a rock, love poured upon our heads like precious oil, love feeding us in the wilderness, love meeting us in the fiery furnace, love filling our cup until it overflows and seating us at a lavish banquet. Christ's love takes us up into the heavenly kingdom. It brings us heaven now. It heals us, so that even in our broken condition, we may glorify God and we may love our brothers, sisters, neighbours and even our enemies.
Picture now the Church, God's pure bride, being cut into a million slivers, every cut being a doctrinal line of division. Is this dissected Bride beautiful? Is she glorious? Is Christ's true Church like a million particles of dust blown across the earth? If you told me God would be ok with that, I would have to conclude that God had abandoned his Bride. No Bridegroom would allow his beloved to be torn apart. No loving God would be pleased to see his children estranged from each other, dividing over doctrine and personal conviction.
You cannot say that God doesn't care whether or not the Church is a singular, united Body, since the Church
is His Body and God is One.
1 Peter 4:8
And above all things have fervent love for one another, for “love will cover a multitude of sins."
John 13:34-35
A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another; as I have loved you, that you also love one another. By this all will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another.
Romans 12:5
so we, being many, are one body in Christ, and individually members of one another.
John 17: 20-23
I do not pray for these alone, but also for those who will believe in Me through their word; that they all may be one, as You, Father, are in Me, and I in You; that they also may be one in Us, that the world may believe that You sent Me. And the glory which You gave Me I have given them, that they may be one just as We are one: I in them, and You in Me; that they may be made perfect in one, and that the world may know that You have sent Me, and have loved them as You have loved Me.
The bottom line is that you don't get to decide what Christianity is. It's not a matter of taste or debate. The Scriptures must not be interpreted in any way that would divide the Body of Christ. They were not written down and given to us so that we could "be Christian" without being in the Church.
Some say "I follow Luther" others say "I follow Calvin" and yet others say "I follow Billy Graham" but Christ is not divided! He has one body and one Church. For those who call themselves Christians, this has an undeniable implication.
May the Love of Christ compel us to reject a divided, broken version of Christianity and choose unity above all else.